Welcome to the Deliberative Democracy Digest

A roundup of recent developments in the theory and practice of deliberative democracy.

Democracy without Shortcuts

Are deliberative minipublics acceptable democratic shortcuts in building a participatory deliberative democracy?

The Challenge of Global Deliberative Democracy

Global citizens’ assemblies can democratise global governance. But how these assemblies are convened needs to be democratised too. 

A Deliberative Democrat in the Jury Room

Do deliberative democrats make good jurors? Sonia Bussu reflects on her experience as a foreperson in a London jury.

Japan Catches the Deliberative Wave

Are we witnessing the rise of a participatory society in Japan? Ayano Takeuchi sends a dispatch from Tokyo.

Articles

Why Millions Can Deliberate: It Just Requires an Economy That Supports Mass Participation

Why Millions Can Deliberate: It Just Requires an Economy That Supports Mass Participation

The recent language of mass governance associated with New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani points toward treating participation as sustained popular involvement in governing itself, through ongoing campaigns, neighborhood-level structures, and participatory democratic processes tied to real policy decisions. What is notable about this is not that it offers a ready-made solution, but that it reopens a question democratic theory has too often closed: how public life might be reorganised so that large numbers of people can participate meaningfully.

read more
Gatekeepers or Guardians? How Governance Upholds Deliberative Integrity in Mini-Publics

Gatekeepers or Guardians? How Governance Upholds Deliberative Integrity in Mini-Publics

The proliferation of deliberative mini-publics has produced an increasing variety in their design and performance, enhancing cooptation concerns. Focusing on Irish Assemblies, Fionna Saintraint argues that safeguarding these processes requires shifting focus from deliberative quality alone to including governance arrangements into analytical evaluations, to reveal how power, interest and accountability operate.

read more
Our democratic nature? Reflections on more-than-human agency and connection.

Our democratic nature? Reflections on more-than-human agency and connection.

In the field of democratic innovation, we are witnessing increasing interest in the theory and practice of including more-than-humans in deliberative and participatory processes. The question of who speaks for more-than-humans, and how they can be meaningfully included, gets to the core of how we understand democratic life itself. In this curated conversation, Lakshmi Venugopal and Shrishtee Bajpai reflect on their experiences exploring what it means in different contexts around the world to include more-than-humans in democracy.

read more
Epistemic Justice and Decolonial Intersectional Futures in Deliberative Democracy

Epistemic Justice and Decolonial Intersectional Futures in Deliberative Democracy

Deliberative democracy’s normative ideals demand epistemic plurality and justice – not only the inclusion of diverse perspectives, but also the recognition of diverse forms and systems of knowledge. In practice, this ideal can fall short. Anna Slaviero examines the Norwegian Education Act’s systemic exclusion of Sámi knowledge from its deliberative consultation process, and suggests theoretical and practical steps towards epistemic justice in deliberative democracy.

read more
The Democratic Odyssey: Design Innovations in Transnational Deliberation

The Democratic Odyssey: Design Innovations in Transnational Deliberation

As the first itinerant transnational citizens’ assembly, the Democratic Odyssey was conceived as an experiment and pilot of what Europe-wide deliberation could look like. In this article, we draw on our first-hand experiences as organisers and observers to reflect on three innovations introduced in the Odyssey’s process design: iterative composition, open consultation on the remit, and centring lived experience.

read more
Does party ideology matter in the commissioning of deliberative mini-publics?

Does party ideology matter in the commissioning of deliberative mini-publics?

Existing research shows that political ideology played an important role in the adoption of Participatory Budgeting in Europe. Is the same true for deliberative mini-publics? Rodrigo Ramis-Moyano, Graham Smith, Ernesto Ganuza and Thamy Pogrebinschi provide the first systematic analysis on this question. They find no clear ideological patterns in the early adoption of mini-publics in Europe, but ideological differentiation when it comes to the designs adopted. These findings show the versatile but ideologically shaped nature of these procedures.

read more
Social capital and resilience: how women’s grassroots participation drives climate adaptation in Sub-Saharan Africa.

Social capital and resilience: how women’s grassroots participation drives climate adaptation in Sub-Saharan Africa.

It is widely known that women are disproportionately impacted by climate change. In this article, Penelope Nortey, Sharon Boateng and Robert C. Richards Jr demonstrate how women are also best placed to develop effective climate action in Sub-Saharan Africa. By delving into the relational and structural dynamics of grassroots participation, they show how women are innovating to address both environmental vulnerabilities and economic security in the face of structural challenges.

read more
Democratising science? Citizen deliberation on climate research in the Netherlands

Democratising science? Citizen deliberation on climate research in the Netherlands

Can citizen deliberation play a role in decision-making within the world of science? What could this look like? These were some of the questions a Netherlands-based team of researchers and practitioners has tried to address in the past year, as they embarked on an experiment to apply the merits of deliberative dialogue to decisions about climate research. Here Remco van der Stoep reflects on the process and lessons from Climate Research in Dialogue.

read more
Activated Citizenship in Conversation

Activated Citizenship in Conversation

In her new book, Activated Citizenship: the transformative power of citizens’ assemblies, Marjan Ehsassi explores the potential of citizens’ assemblies to address some of the challenges facing contemporary Western democracies. In this interview, Marjan is joined by John Gastil to reflect on key themes from the book. Drawing on both their research and life experiences, this conversation is a thoughtful reflection on citizens’ assemblies covering both the details of the process and the macropolitical challenges and potentials.

read more
The Ostbelgien Model: five years on

The Ostbelgien Model: five years on

In 2019, a corner of Belgium made history when it established a new form of institutionalised citizen deliberation. Five years after its inception, the team of researchers following it reflect on the ongoing learnings emerging from the Ostbelgien Model.

read more
Building meaningful collaborations with young people in participatory democracy

Building meaningful collaborations with young people in participatory democracy

There are increasing efforts to involve young people in participatory research and governance, but meaningful, impactful collaboration is often constrained by institutional and structural barriers. In this in-depth conversation, Journal of Deliberative Democracy co-editor Sonia Bussu talks to civic practitioner Katy Rubin and Stuart Dunne from Youth Focus North West (UK) about youth participation. They reflect on the challenges of doing participatory work with youth under conditions that are sub-optimal for enhancing voice and empowerment, and offer their tips for practitioners and researchers engaging with young people.

read more
Mini-publics and the public: challenges and opportunities

Mini-publics and the public: challenges and opportunities

The broader public being aware of and engaged with the work of deliberative mini-publics is central to their democratic value. Yet, how to generate this engagement in practice remains relatively underexplored. In this conversation, Sarah Castell and Stephen Elstub discuss why public engagement is so important – and so challenging.

read more
Make it make sense: the challenge of data analysis in global deliberation

Make it make sense: the challenge of data analysis in global deliberation

Global Deliberative processes are gaining traction, and they bring with them a fresh set of challenges for design and implementation. Not least is the question of how to systematise discussions from thousands of citizens across languages and cultures. In this piece, Iñaki Goñi discusses his work with ISWE Foundation developing a data strategy that looks beyond “Big Data” by foregrounding “Little Data” along with a normative commitment to democratising how and by whom that data is curated.

read more

Supporters

The Journal of Deliberative Democracy and Deliberative Democracy Digest are supported by:

Contact

General queries

Please get in touch with our editor Lucy Parry.

Mailing Address

Journal of Deliberative Democracy
Centre for Deliberative Democracy and Global Governance
Ann Harding Conference Centre
University Drive South
University of Canberra, ACT 2617

Twitter

@delibdemjournal